Menu
The Crumb Picker, Inc. is a home-based start up baking company. Pick up is available on *most* Fridays and Saturday mornings in Farmingdale, NY. All items are made-to-order and orders MUST be placed in advance. At least one week notice is recommended. Please check social media (@the_crumb_picker) for the most current monthly menu and availability!
To inquire about placing an order, please send a direct message during regular business hours through The Crumb Picker, Inc. Facebook or Instagram page, email: thecrumbpicker@gmail.com, or send a text message to (516) 835-1164.
Forms of payment accepted include cash at pickup or Vemno in advance.
Classic New York Crumb Cake
The classic New York crumb cake features a light and fluffy vanilla cake topped with delicious, buttery crumbs that are the perfect balance of cinnamon and sugar goodness.
8x8 cake (serves 9-12 people) - $32
Funfetti - $33
Red Velvet Crumb Cake
Light yet decadent, the Red Velvet crumb cake is pure red velvet perfection. It is topped with our signature buttery crumbs and a chocolate ganache drizzle.
8x8 cake (serves 9-12 people) - $35
Lemon Poppy Crumb Cake
A lemon poppyseed butter cake infused with lemon zest and topped with a light lemon icing.
8x8 cake (serves 9-12 people) - $35
Cookies and Cream Crumb Cake
Traditional vanilla cake loaded with Oreo pieces from the crumb layer all the way through to the cake.
8x8 cake (serves 9-12 people) - $35
Chocolate Chip Cookies
These famous thin buttery delights are slightly crispy on the edge and super soft in the center. We bet you can’t eat just one!
Per Dozen - $18
Just Crumbs
Let’s face it - some people’s favorite part of the crumb cake is the top: the crumbs! For this reason, we offer Just Crumbs. This cinnamon sugar butter crumb cookie is baked to perfection and topped with confectioners sugar.
Traditional w/powdered sugar - $15 for 12
Chocolate dipped crumbs - $18 for 12
Baby Cakes - Mini Traditional Crumb Cakes
These delicious traditional crumb cakes pack the same flavor punch as their big mamas. Weighing in at just under a pound, these 5x4 crumb cakes are the perfect treat for those who just want a taste, as a party favor or gift, or a delicious midnight snack. Each cake yields two large slices or four smaller slices.
Per cake - starts at $15*
Funfetti mini crumb cake - $16
*pricing for baby cakes as party favors varies depending on packaging needs and quantity.
This menu will rotate. Check social media for the most current offerings. The above does not include seasonal items that are offered on occasion throughout the year. Other pricing and quantity limits may apply.
Prices and menu items are subject to change. While our baked goods are made with a whole lot of love, they also contain eggs, wheat, and milk ingredients. They are prepared in a kitchen that uses peanuts and tree nuts.